"50 Shades of Grey": Yay or nay?

Screen Legend

Legendary
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
966
Location
Canada
I've been debating about where to put this because even though the title of the movie is in the subject line, I really want to discuss the CONTENT and "relationship" that people have like this.

I am not judgemental, but I AM of the opinion that this type of stuff is wrong and should be unacceptable. I get that people have freaky tastes - I mean there's a post in this forum about a man who had an affair with a DOLPHIN - but that doesn't mean it is acceptable. I don't know. I've been brought up to know that hitting a woman is WRONG...and then I find out later that in some sexual relationships it's okay as long as you have their consent [same goes for the man]. I mean...WHAT?! o_O

I just don't find this kind of thing 'attractive'. It seems to advocate FOR abusive relationships instead of against. I don't like it.

And the Jian Ghomeshi thing here in Canada is exactly what I'm talking about. My mom can not understand why he is being charged with this and this and this when other people are probably into all into this kind of stuff since 50Shades of Grey came out. I tried to explain it to her, TWICE, but she still doesn't get it.

What do you guys think? I may be a prude but I have the absolute respect for any and all people so I really don't understand this kind of thing.

I watched an episode of Forever with this kind of thing in it and I just felt...disgust [even if it DID give me an AI of Hilarie Burton for a character I'm currently developing ;)].
 
let me begin by saying "50 shades of gray" is a WEAK ASS BOOK. If you want a REAL book that has erotica & soft-core porn overtones that explores role play, domination, bi-sexuality & more...try Emmanuelle. Now THAT is a good book! :D

ANYWAY, to the point ofyour topic, you're doing exactly what you should do on this board, be honest w/ your feelings & opinions so that we can discuss. :)

Speaking for myself, I DO enjoy a certain level of rough play & "struggle" in the bedroom, BUT not to the point where a man is HITTING ME or beating my ass LOL! HELL NO!

BUT I like to "antagonize" a man, get him to be a bit aggressive.

this is all understood & mutually agreed to BEFORE we even go down that road. No man is going to come in my house & tie ME up & smack me around (although I'm not opposed to doing that to HIM if that's what he wants :D )

When it comes to sex, my opinion is GENERALLY "The skies the limit" BUT I draw a RED LINE @ beastiality (i.e. man & dolphin LOL ) , pedophilia & necrophilia...oh & scat too...<< SHUDDER...VOMIT!>>

If you're not engaging in any of those things I "red lined"...then GREAT! GO FOR IT! If you like it, I LOVE IT! lol

It's a big world out here & sex CAN get boring if it's done the same way all the time, everytime.

Jian Gomeshi (I'm familiar w/ him down here b/c I listened to his program "Q" on NPR regularly) screwed up b/c apparently some of the women have alleged that what he did to them was NOT with their consent. One of the women has defended him but she also admitted that he had her full consent. If you're going to do ANYTHING "out of the ordinary" w/ someone...there MUST be mutual trust, understanding & clear, expressed CONSENT first & foremost. After that? its really dependent upon you, your imagination & how far you're willing to go.
Like i said, I like a lil spice in the bedroom, BUT aint NO MAN slapping ME around LOL!
 
Last edited:
Can't say that I understand it either... but I don't really care what other people do.
As long as it's mutual, with consent and all that of course.

I do think it's kinda begging of trouble though and I'm not sure how people dare to do rough stuff even if consent has been given.

Personally I don't have it in me.
I don't even know how to be aggressive. lol

/SK
 
I'll be giving this a miss. The book was just so badly written and it was a Twilight fan fic, which I also have issues with. I don't really want to repeat everything but I posted this on Facebook and this sums up how I feel. Click Me

I do fee a bit for Jamie Dornan as he is a very good actor, watch The Fall if you don't believe me.
 
I knew you wouldn't need convincing. Convincing you that he is fab is like someone trying to convince me that Tom Hiddleston is a true Disney prince.
 
Karma
Karma
don't you mean CHRIS PINE is a true disney prince?! :p ^_^
Well, he is.

I have not watched season 2 yet. I meant to this past weekend and just didn't have the uninterrupted time that it would call for :)
 
The only reason people read this book was for the sex, same for watching the film. On Feb 14 2015 the Western World took part in the largest ever bout of voyuerism. You naughty buggers..

Me, I met a couple who were swingers, swappers and generally up for a gangbang/party. They had mutually agreed rules and without knowing this you couldn't say that they didn't love each other.

I met another women that claimed every woman has had (and enjoyed) the rape fantasy, the cheating fantasy and the multiple man fantasy.

(These are just two examples) what I learned on my travels is that sex has very few rules, what is between consenting individuals is between them and as long as it is mutual consent its not my place to judge.

It is OK to get your freak on.
 
The only reason people read this book was for the sex, same for watching the film. On Feb 14 2015 the Western World took part in the largest ever bout of voyuerism. You naughty buggers..

Me, I met a couple who were swingers, swappers and generally up for a gangbang/party. They had mutually agreed rules and without knowing this you couldn't say that they didn't love each other.

I met another women that claimed every woman has had (and enjoyed) the rape fantasy, the cheating fantasy and the multiple man fantasy.

(These are just two examples) what I learned on my travels is that sex has very few rules, what is between consenting individuals is between them and as long as it is mutual consent its not my place to judge.

It is OK to get your freak on.

[the part i highlighted] hmmm....*I* dont know about THAT :confused:

but to everything else, I agree ;) Too bad you didnt "travel" THIS way @ some point :p lol !
 
Indeed, I'm all but retired these days, a flash of ankle as I'm good for the week - parenthood.

But yeah her rape fantasy comment was a tad, extreme I thought but drums home the point that sex is different for everyone. This is where sexual compatibility comes into play.

Anyway, 50 shades of gray read like I wrote it.
 
I have found in my travels that different women have different tastes. The advantage of being a large guy is that women usually have a fetish or two to play out when it comes to me. I have been the intruder, the hostage-taker, the hero who got the spoils, the dominant one, the shy guy, the....whatever gets them where they want to be. In exchange, I have had one hell of a time in my life and pushed many boundaries.

In my experience, a couple should be honest and up front about what they want and what they don't want. After that, they should be open to some negotiation based on trust. Some people will have true red lines, but I have found that a surprising amount of things are on the table if you know how to ask for it...
 
Karma
Karma
hostage-taker? wow! you'll have to tell me how that unfolds LOL!
Oh, and 50 Shades seems rapey and uncool. And I am no fan of the 'billionaire white guy can do whatever he wants to whomever he wants' vibe I get from it.
 
Karma
Karma
LOL you should check out what Madonna had to say about it (the thread is in the movies forum) ! when the woman who literally wrote the book on SEX says it's not sexy? you definitely FAILED LOL!
Oh, and 50 Shades seems rapey and uncool. And I am no fan of the 'billionaire white guy can do whatever he wants to whomever he wants' vibe I get from it.

I havent seen the film but the book is over hyped fer sure & when Madonna (the woman who literally wrote the book on "SEX") says it's not sexy? you know you've FAILED! LOL
 
"50 Shades..." = major nay for me.
We're not even talking real BDSM when it concerns the book. Personally I consider real BDSM, with real and responsible people, something anyone outside of that bedroom shouldn't be concerned with. I've been a member of a BDSM club myself and that lifestyle is in my experience vastly different from what the author of Shades has cooked up...

The book is straight up abuse.
It's emotional and mental manipulation from an insecure asshat of a guy who uses physical dominance and the emotional immaturity of an inexperienced girl to create his unwilling submissive. When she says no he threatens her, when she's insecure he overpowers her either with sex or manipulation... he relentlessly stalks her, even when she clearly asks for him to leave her alone... It's super creepy and very disturbing.

To boot it uses a troubled past as an "excuse" to treat another person this way (it's not) and perpetuates the dangerous idea that a woman's love is all that's needed to redeem or "cure" a guy like Christian.

In my opinion EL James and her publishers owes the world and most of all the BDSM community a great big apology for putting this crap out there.
 
I had a brief moment of happiness when it was reported that Jamie Dornan wouldn't be doing the sequel.

Oh and @Carol Peletier nope I don't mean Chris Pine as a Disney Prince....I have evidence on the Hiddles as Disney Prince but I won't hijack the thread on that - when I wake up properly i'll post it on your page ;)
 
Back
Top